Common claim denial reasons, and how to catch them before you submit
Short answer
Most claim denials trace back to a short list of causes: missing or wrong patient and payer data, eligibility and prior authorization gaps, coding errors, diagnoses that don't support the procedure, duplicates and late filing. Many of them can be caught before submission by scrubbing each claim against coding edits and the payer's own rules.
Key facts
- CARC 16: the claim lacks information or has submission or billing errors.
- CARC 11: the diagnosis is inconsistent with the procedure.
- CARC 50: the service is not deemed a medical necessity by the payer.
- CARC 97: the service is included in the payment for another service (bundling).
- CARC 197: precertification or authorization was absent.
- CARC 18: exact duplicate claim or service.
- CARC 29: the time limit for filing has expired.
How are denials reported?
Payers explain each adjustment on the electronic remittance advice (the X12 835) with a Claim Adjustment Reason Code (CARC), a group code such as CO (contractual obligation) or PR (patient responsibility), and often a Remittance Advice Remark Code (RARC) with more detail. So a medical-necessity denial the provider has to absorb appears as CO-50.
What are the most common causes?
Each common cause has a check that catches it before the claim goes out:
- Missing or invalid data: member ID, birth date, sex, service dates and NPIs. Check every required field, and validate NPIs with their check digit.
- Eligibility and prior authorization: check coverage, and apply each payer’s authorization rules to the codes on the claim.
- Coding errors: invalid or non-billable ICD-10 codes, Excludes1 conflicts, missing code-first codes, wrong POA indicators, and badly formed CPT, HCPCS or modifiers.
- Medical necessity: a procedure with no diagnosis on the claim that supports it.
- Duplicates: repeated claim IDs or service lines.
- Timely filing: claims sent after the payer’s deadline. Track the filing window from the date of service.
What is claim scrubbing?
Claim scrubbing checks every claim against a set of edits before it is submitted: built-in coding, billing, provider, patient and claim-data checks, plus the payer-specific rules your team has learned from past denials. Failed checks are ranked so the riskiest claims are fixed first, and the corrected file is scrubbed again before it goes out.
Which denials can't a scrubber catch?
A scrubber checks the claim, not the chart. Clinical validation denials, where the payer says the record doesn't support a diagnosis such as sepsis or malnutrition, need a check of each code against the clinical notes, and a physician query when the documentation is unclear.