CDI

How to write a compliant physician query (with an example)

By Claimino · Updated · 2 min read

Short answer

A compliant physician query asks the provider to clarify the documentation without leading them to a particular answer. It quotes the clinical indicators from the record, offers clinically reasonable options including 'other' and 'unable to determine', and never mentions payment or the effect on the DRG.

Key facts

  • The reference is the AHIMA/ACDIS Guidelines for Achieving a Compliant Query Practice.
  • A query is leading if it points to one answer, omits clinical indicators, or mentions financial impact.
  • Multiple-choice queries should include clinically reasonable options, plus other and unable to determine.
  • Yes/no queries are not for new diagnoses: keep them for questions such as present-on-admission status or confirming a diagnosis already in the record.
  • Keep queries and answers with the record or the business record, according to your policy.

When should you query?

Query when the documentation is:

  • Conflicting, for example between the attending and a consultant.
  • Incomplete, such as a condition being treated with no diagnosis stated.
  • Ambiguous or imprecise, such as a diagnosis without its type, severity or cause.
  • Clinically unsupported, where a diagnosis is documented without the indicators for it.
  • Unclear on present-on-admission status.

Which query format should you use?

Open-ended queries ask the provider to describe a condition in their own words. Multiple-choice queries list reasonable options drawn from the indicators in the record. Yes/no queries suit narrow questions, such as whether a condition was present on admission, and shouldn’t be used to introduce a diagnosis that isn’t already documented.

What makes a query leading?

  • Offering only one diagnosis to agree with.
  • Leaving out the clinical indicators, so the provider is asked to agree rather than to judge.
  • Mentioning reimbursement, the DRG or quality scores.
  • Introducing a diagnosis that has no support in the record.

Example: a multiple-choice query

Illustrative only. Clinical indicators from the record: dietitian assessment on day 2 notes intake below 50% of estimated needs for more than 5 days, weight loss of 6% in one month, and moderate loss of muscle mass at the temples and shoulders. A high-protein supplement was started.

Based on these indicators, can you clarify the patient’s nutritional status? Options: severe protein-calorie malnutrition; moderate protein-calorie malnutrition; mild protein-calorie malnutrition; other (please specify); unable to determine.